Back to topics

Where does a helpful analogy stop being helpful?

Calling the heart a pump helps connect an unfamiliar system with a familiar one. The comparison becomes less helpful when a listener carries over a feature that the two systems do not actually share.

3–7 min

Questions you could explore

  • Which useful inference might an analogy invite, and which mistaken inference might come with it?

Start reading

Ready to try your ideas aloud?

Your topic carries over. Record up to 2½ minutes, depending on your plan.

Communication

Why can the same pause mean different things?

A pause after a difficult question can sound thoughtful. A pause after a joke can feel like rejection. Silence has no words, yet we interpret it against the response we expected and the relationship we think we have.

4–6 min

Why can the same pause mean different things?

Communication4–6 minA pause after a difficult question can sound thoughtful. A pause after a joke can feel like rejection. Silence has no words, yet we interpret it against the response we expected and the relationship we think we have.

Communication

Could we leave a warning that survives 10,000 years?

Imagine making a warning for people whose language and symbols you cannot predict. The object must survive, someone must find it, and its meaning must still be recognizable. A Sandia report on nuclear-waste markers treats those as separate design problems, rather than assuming a durable sign will stay understandable.

3–7 min

Could we leave a warning that survives 10,000 years?

Communication3–7 minImagine making a warning for people whose language and symbols you cannot predict. The object must survive, someone must find it, and its meaning must still be recognizable. A Sandia report on nuclear-waste markers treats those as separate design problems, rather than assuming a durable sign will stay understandable.

Communication

What can your hands say that your sentence leaves out?

Someone says an object was “this big,” and their hands supply the missing dimensions. Gestures can also convey ideas that differ from the accompanying words. In one study of children explaining math problems, researchers examined what adults did with those additional clues.

3–7 min

What can your hands say that your sentence leaves out?

Communication3–7 minSomeone says an object was “this big,” and their hands supply the missing dimensions. Gestures can also convey ideas that differ from the accompanying words. In one study of children explaining math problems, researchers examined what adults did with those additional clues.

Where does a helpful analogy stop being helpful? | Speech Topic | speaking.app