What changes when you have to explain exactly how your opinion would work?
Supporting a proposal and explaining the steps by which it would produce a result are different tasks. Experiments on political policies asked people for detailed causal explanations rather than just reasons for their views. Discovering a gap in an explanation can reveal uncertainty without, by itself, proving the position wrong.
Questions you could explore
- Which link between the proposal and its intended result is least clear?
Start reading
- www.psychologicalscience.orgAPS: illusion of explanatory depth and political extremity
The abstract distinguishes explaining how a policy works from listing reasons to support it. Full methods are needed to assess the experiments in detail.
Ready to try your ideas aloud?
Your topic carries over. Record up to 2½ minutes, depending on your plan.