Back to topics

Was it the person, or the situation?

Someone’s abrupt reply can suggest several explanations: a lasting habit, an unusually difficult day, or something else. Dispositional and situational explanations place the emphasis differently, and an observation alone may leave both open.

3–5 min

Questions you could explore

  • What extra information would help distinguish a personal tendency from a response to circumstances?
  • How might both influences operate together?

Start reading

Ready to try your ideas aloud?

Your topic carries over. Record up to 2½ minutes, depending on your plan.

Psychology

Can an option nobody wants change what people choose?

Choosing between two offers can feel different when a third appears beside them. A decoy is less attractive than one option on the relevant features, but its presence does not reliably change every decision.

5–7 min
Psychology

Can a question change what someone remembers?

A question can ask for a memory while also suggesting what might have happened. Research on eyewitness reports separates what someone originally saw from information introduced afterward, making wording part of the evidence problem.

3–7 min
Was it the person, or the situation? | Speech Topic | speaking.app